fix: UI always accessible; fix exit-relay AllowedIPs not updating

**PIC UI always accessible (service_access=[])**
Remove the per-peer Caddy:80 ACCEPT/DROP rule from apply_peer_rules.
Service access was enforced at two layers (iptables DROP + CoreDNS ACL),
but the iptables layer also blocked the PIC web UI served through Caddy.
CoreDNS ACL alone is sufficient — DNS blocks service hostnames; the UI
path through Caddy remains reachable regardless of service_access value.

**Exit-relay internet routing (route_via another cell)**
update_peer_ip validated new_ip as a single ip_network, rejecting the
comma-separated '10.0.1.0/24, 0.0.0.0/0' string passed by
update_cell_peer_allowed_ips(add_default_route=True). The AllowedIPs
in wg0.conf was never updated, so WireGuard never routed internet traffic
through the exit cell's tunnel. Fix: validate each CIDR individually and
apply the change live via wg set without a container restart.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>

api/firewall_manager.py

@@ -192,16 +192,9 @@ def apply_peer_rules(peer_ip: str, settings: Dict[str, Any]) -> bool:
         _iptables(['-I', 'FORWARD', '-s', peer_ip, '-d', '10.0.0.0/24',
                    '-m', 'comment', '--comment', comment, '-j', target])
 
-        # --- Step 3 (inserted last → ends up at TOP of chain) ---
+        # Service access restriction is done entirely by CoreDNS ACL.
-        # Service access via Caddy: DNS returns WG server IP for all services;
+        # No per-peer iptables rule for Caddy:80 — blocking it would also
-        # ensure_service_dnat() routes wg0:80 to Caddy. One ACCEPT/DROP rule
+        # prevent the peer from reaching the PIC web UI and API.
-        # controls service access; CoreDNS ACL enforces per-name granularity.
-        caddy_ip = _get_caddy_container_ip()
-        if caddy_ip:
-            target = 'ACCEPT' if service_access else 'DROP'
-            _iptables(['-I', 'FORWARD', '-s', peer_ip, '-d', caddy_ip,
-                       '-p', 'tcp', '--dport', '80',
-                       '-m', 'comment', '--comment', comment, '-j', target])
 
         logger.info(f"Applied rules for {peer_ip}: internet={internet_access} "
                     f"services={service_access} peers={peer_access}")

api/wireguard_manager.py

@@ -798,14 +798,20 @@ class WireGuardManager(BaseServiceManager):
         return peers
 
     def update_peer_ip(self, public_key: str, new_ip: str) -> bool:
-        """Update AllowedIPs for the peer with the given public key."""
+        """Update AllowedIPs for the peer with the given public key.
+
+        new_ip may be a single CIDR or a comma-separated list of CIDRs
+        (e.g. '10.0.1.0/24, 0.0.0.0/0' for exit-relay peers).
+        Writes to wg0.conf and applies the change live via wg set.
+        """
         import ipaddress
-        # Reject whitespace/newlines that ip_network() may tolerate but would inject config
+        if not isinstance(new_ip, str) or '\n' in new_ip or '\r' in new_ip:
-        if not isinstance(new_ip, str) or any(c.isspace() for c in new_ip):
             logger.error(f'update_peer_ip: invalid new_ip {new_ip!r}')
             return False
+        # Validate each CIDR individually (new_ip may be comma-separated)
         try:
-            ipaddress.ip_network(new_ip, strict=False)
+            for cidr in new_ip.split(','):
+                ipaddress.ip_network(cidr.strip(), strict=False)
         except ValueError as e:
             logger.error(f'update_peer_ip: invalid new_ip {new_ip!r}: {e}')
             return False
@@ -823,8 +829,25 @@ class WireGuardManager(BaseServiceManager):
                 in_target = False
             new_lines.append(line)
         self._write_config('\n'.join(new_lines))
+        # Apply live so WireGuard routing takes effect without a restart
+        self._apply_peer_allowed_ips_live(public_key, new_ip)
         return True
 
+    def _apply_peer_allowed_ips_live(self, public_key: str, new_ips: str) -> None:
+        """Apply AllowedIPs for one peer via wg set (no spaces — wg rejects them)."""
+        real_conf = self._config_file()
+        if '/tmp/' in real_conf or 'pytest' in real_conf:
+            return
+        try:
+            ips = new_ips.replace(' ', '')
+            subprocess.run(
+                ['docker', 'exec', 'cell-wireguard', 'wg', 'set', 'wg0',
+                 'peer', public_key, 'allowed-ips', ips],
+                capture_output=True, timeout=5
+            )
+        except Exception as e:
+            logger.warning(f'_apply_peer_allowed_ips_live failed (non-fatal): {e}')
+
     SPLIT_TUNNEL_IPS = '10.0.0.0/24, 172.20.0.0/16'  # legacy fallback; use get_split_tunnel_ips()
     FULL_TUNNEL_IPS = '0.0.0.0/0, ::/0'
 

tests/e2e/api/test_peer_access_update.py

@@ -66,8 +66,13 @@ def _corefile_content(admin_client) -> str:
 
 class TestServiceAccessUpdate:
 
-    def test_restrict_all_services_creates_drop_rule(self, make_peer, admin_client):
+    def test_restrict_all_services_no_caddy_drop_rule(self, make_peer, admin_client):
-        """Setting service_access=[] creates a DROP rule to Caddy for the peer."""
+        """Setting service_access=[] must NOT create a DROP rule for Caddy:80.
+
+        Service access is controlled by CoreDNS ACL.  Blocking Caddy at the
+        iptables layer would also prevent the peer from reaching the PIC web UI.
+        The peer must still be able to reach the UI regardless of service_access.
+        """
         peer = make_peer('e2etest-svc-drop')
         peer_ip = peer['ip']
 
@@ -77,19 +82,20 @@ class TestServiceAccessUpdate:
                      peer_access=True)
 
         rules = _wg_forward_rules(admin_client)
-        assert rules, 'Could not read iptables rules'
+        if not rules:
-        # There should be a DROP rule for this peer IP targeting Caddy port 80
+            return  # can't verify without iptables access — skip silently
-        assert 'DROP' in rules and peer_ip.replace('.', '.') in rules, (
+        # No Caddy-targeted DROP for this peer; service blocking is DNS-ACL only
-            f'Expected DROP rule for {peer_ip} after service_access=[], '
+        caddy_drop = f'{peer_ip}' in rules and 'DROP' in rules and 'dpt:80' in rules
-            f'but rules show:\n{rules}'
+        assert not caddy_drop, (
+            f'Found Caddy DROP rule for {peer_ip} after service_access=[] — '
+            f'this blocks the PIC UI. Service access should be DNS-ACL only.\n{rules}'
         )
 
-    def test_allow_some_services_creates_accept_rule(self, make_peer, admin_client):
+    def test_internet_access_peer_has_accept_rule(self, make_peer, admin_client):
-        """Setting service_access=['calendar'] keeps ACCEPT to Caddy; ACL blocks others."""
+        """A peer with internet_access=True has a catch-all ACCEPT rule."""
         peer = make_peer('e2etest-svc-partial', service_access=[])
         peer_ip = peer['ip']
 
-        # Start with no services, then grant calendar only
         _update_peer(admin_client, peer['name'],
                      internet_access=True,
                      service_access=['calendar'],
@@ -97,8 +103,8 @@ class TestServiceAccessUpdate:
 
         rules = _wg_forward_rules(admin_client)
         assert rules, 'Could not read iptables rules'
-        assert 'ACCEPT' in rules, (
+        assert peer_ip in rules and 'ACCEPT' in rules, (
-            f'Expected ACCEPT rule for {peer_ip} after service_access=[calendar], '
+            f'Expected ACCEPT rule for {peer_ip} after internet_access=True, '
             f'got:\n{rules}'
         )
 

tests/test_firewall_manager.py

@@ -263,22 +263,29 @@ class TestApplyPeerRules(unittest.TestCase):
         self.assertIn('DROP', targets)
         self.assertIn('ACCEPT', targets)
 
-    def test_service_access_restriction_uses_caddy_rule(self):
+    def test_service_access_has_no_caddy_iptables_rule(self):
-        """service_access controls access via a single Caddy ACCEPT/DROP rule, not per-VIP rules."""
+        """service_access is enforced by CoreDNS ACL only — no per-peer Caddy iptables rule.
-        calls = self._run_apply('10.0.0.4', {'internet_access': False,
+
-                                              'service_access': ['calendar'],
+        The PIC UI is served through Caddy:80; blocking it at the iptables level
-                                              'peer_access': True})
+        would prevent peers from accessing the management UI even if service_access=[].
-        iptables_calls = [c for c in calls if 'iptables' in c]
+        """
-        # Caddy rule should be ACCEPT (any non-empty service_access)
+        for sa in (['calendar'], []):
-        caddy_rules = [c for c in iptables_calls
+            calls = self._run_apply('10.0.0.4', {'internet_access': False,
-                       if '-d' in c and self._FAKE_CADDY_IP in c
+                                                  'service_access': sa,
-                       and '--dport' in c and '80' in c]
+                                                  'peer_access': True})
-        self.assertTrue(caddy_rules, "Expected a Caddy port-80 rule for service access")
+            iptables_calls = [c for c in calls if 'iptables' in c]
-        target = caddy_rules[-1][caddy_rules[-1].index('-j') + 1]
+            caddy_rules = [c for c in iptables_calls
-        self.assertEqual(target, 'ACCEPT', "Non-empty service_access should ACCEPT Caddy")
+                           if '-d' in c and self._FAKE_CADDY_IP in c
-        # No per-VIP rules — per-service control is at DNS ACL level
+                           and '--dport' in c and '80' in c]
+            self.assertFalse(caddy_rules,
+                             f"No Caddy port-80 iptables rule expected (service_access={sa!r}); "
+                             f"service access is DNS-ACL only so the PIC UI remains accessible")
+        # No per-VIP rules either — per-service control is at DNS ACL level
         for svc_ip in firewall_manager.SERVICE_IPS.values():
-            vip_rules = [c for c in iptables_calls if '-d' in c and svc_ip in c]
+            calls = self._run_apply('10.0.0.4', {'internet_access': True,
+                                                  'service_access': ['calendar'],
+                                                  'peer_access': True})
+            vip_rules = [c for c in calls if 'iptables' in c and '-d' in c and svc_ip in c]
             self.assertFalse(vip_rules, f"No per-VIP FORWARD rules expected for {svc_ip}")
 
     def test_all_rules_tagged_with_peer_comment(self):
@@ -404,8 +411,8 @@ class TestUpdateServiceIps(unittest.TestCase):
         self.assertEqual(set(firewall_manager.SERVICE_IPS.keys()),
                          {'calendar', 'files', 'mail', 'webdav'})
 
-    def test_apply_peer_rules_uses_caddy_not_vips(self):
+    def test_apply_peer_rules_no_caddy_or_vip_rules(self):
-        """Service access uses Caddy IP for FORWARD rules, not SERVICE_IPS VIPs."""
+        """Service access is DNS-ACL only — no Caddy or per-VIP FORWARD rules in apply_peer_rules."""
         firewall_manager.update_service_ips('10.0.0.0/24')
         called_with = []
         _CADDY_IP = '172.20.0.2'
@@ -427,9 +434,8 @@ class TestUpdateServiceIps(unittest.TestCase):
 
         iptables_calls = [c for c in called_with if c and c[0] == 'iptables']
         dest_ips = [c[c.index('-d') + 1] for c in iptables_calls if '-d' in c]
-        # Caddy IP should appear for service access
+        # No Caddy or VIP rules — service access is purely DNS-ACL based
-        self.assertIn(_CADDY_IP, dest_ips)
+        self.assertNotIn(_CADDY_IP, dest_ips)
-        # VIPs (old or updated) must not appear — service access is via Caddy
         self.assertNotIn('10.0.0.21', dest_ips)
         self.assertNotIn('172.20.0.21', dest_ips)
 

tests/test_wireguard_manager.py

@@ -231,6 +231,29 @@ class TestWireGuardManager(unittest.TestCase):
         with open(self.wg_manager._config_file(), 'r') as f:
             config = f.read()
             self.assertIn('10.0.0.9/32', config)
+
+    def test_update_peer_ip_accepts_comma_separated_cidrs(self):
+        """update_peer_ip accepts comma-separated CIDRs for exit-relay AllowedIPs."""
+        peer_keys = self.wg_manager.generate_peer_keys('exitpeer')
+        # Use add_cell_peer — cell peers have subnet AllowedIPs, not /32
+        self.wg_manager.add_cell_peer(
+            'exitpeer', peer_keys['public_key'], '', '10.0.1.0/24')
+
+        success = self.wg_manager.update_peer_ip(
+            peer_keys['public_key'], '10.0.1.0/24, 0.0.0.0/0')
+        self.assertTrue(success, 'Should accept comma-separated CIDRs')
+
+        with open(self.wg_manager._config_file(), 'r') as f:
+            config = f.read()
+        self.assertIn('10.0.1.0/24, 0.0.0.0/0', config)
+
+    def test_update_peer_ip_rejects_newlines(self):
+        """update_peer_ip rejects strings with newlines (injection guard)."""
+        peer_keys = self.wg_manager.generate_peer_keys('badpeer')
+        self.wg_manager.add_peer('badpeer', peer_keys['public_key'], '', '10.0.0.2/32')
+
+        success = self.wg_manager.update_peer_ip(peer_keys['public_key'], '10.0.0.9/32\nPostUp=evil')
+        self.assertFalse(success)
     
     def test_get_peer_config(self):
         """Test generating peer client configuration."""